![]() |
![]() |
|
![]() |
|||||||||||||
![]() » November - December 2006 Newsletter
THE ESPA EXPRESS
NEWSLETTER OF THE
To join ESPA, receive the complete newsletter
November - December 2006Vol. 30, No. 6
The View from the Cab
The recent election has (hopefully) provided a reason for renewed optimism among passenger rail advocates, both here in New York State and across the nation.
New Hudson Valley Express Train in Timetable But Not Yet Running
The first tangible improvement to be initiated by the State Senate High Speed Rail Task Force will likely be the introduction of a new weekday Albany to New York roundtrip express train. It is already in the new Empire Corridor Fall schedules with a footnote that service will begin “on a date to be announced.”
Empire Corridor Schedule ChangesAmtrak’s revised Fall and Winter schedules took effect nationwide October 30. Changes for trains serving New York State include: •#280, running weekdays from Niagara Falls to New York, is now timed to arrive in Albany at 9:45am and reach New York by 12:25pm. These earlier arrival times make same-day business trips to Albany more convenient and re-establish connections to the southbound Crescent at Penn Station. •#290, the Ethan Allen Express, running Tuesday through Friday from Rutland, assumes the 11:00am departure slot from Albany, now arriving in New York at 1:25pm •#49, the westbound Lake Shore Limited now leaves New York for upstate points and Chicago at 3:45pm pm on weekends and 4:00pm on weekdays. Arrival at Buffalo Depew is pushed back to 11:55pm each day. In order to address ongoing on-time performance problems across upstate, Amtrak retained some of the extra time added to the schedules of western New York trains for the summer. The best Albany to Buffalo Depew running time is now 4 hours 50 minutes.
Boardman to Serve on Amtrak Board
Transportation Secretary Mary Peters has appointed Federal Railroad Administrator Joseph Boardman to represent her on Amtrak’s Board of Directors. He will replace Jeff Rosen, who represented former Secretary Norman Mineta.
This is good to hear, because most of the trains on this route originate in New York and therefore affect New Yorkers directly. But Boardman discussed other routes as well, and it was most refreshing to hear a highly placed Bush Administration official demonstrate understanding and concern for long distance trains.
Luggage Inspection Trial Starts In Buffalo
On November 7th Amtrak passengers at the Buffalo-Depew station encountered a new rail travel experience; an inspection of their carry-on bags by Transportation Security Administration personal for potential explosive residue.
Empire Corridor Ridership Gains ContinueNew York State rail routes showed strong ridership gains August 2005 to August 2006. Ethan Allen lead the group with a 25.5% ridership gain and a 30.2%increase in revenue. The effects of Amtrak “revenue management” are evident as revenue growth exceeded ridership gains for all routes except Vermonter and Adirondack. The NEC spine data includes Acela, Metroliner and Regional trains on the Northeast corridor.
Ben Gottfried
Moynihan/Penn Back to Drawing BoardAssembly Speaker Sheldon Silver brought an end to the current negotiations to convert the historic General Post Office across the street from Penn Station in Manhattan into a new gateway station for regional and intercity rail in New York City. This places the issue squarely in the new Governor’s lap. Many transit activists were lukewarm to the Post Office plan because some 80% of the travelers using Penn Station would be better served by an upgrade of facilities at its existing location which lies between the 7th and 8th Avenue subways. Many architects and urbanists could appreciate the vision of the late Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan, who saw in the landmarked McKim, Meade and White General Post Office structure an opportunity to recreate what was lost in one of the greatest acts of architectural vandalism – the destruction of the magnificent original Penn Station. Perhaps fortunately, a dose of realism prevailed. While the original Penn Station design had ceremonial staircases that led down to the concourse and platforms, the equally grand staircase at the Post Office leads up to a lobby where stamp windows and other postal services are located. The Post Office building was little more than a hollow facade for a new station located below. The attention now turns to the more serious problem of finding an attractive way to handle the masses of commuters and intercity travelers that use the existing station. While removing the Madison Square Garden arena that replaced the high-ceilinged concourse and waiting room of the original Penn Station would permit a restoration of these large public rooms, it is really at the level just above the tracks where the greatest need exists for more elbow room for passengers. In its original design as a terminal for long distance trains, arriving and departing passengers were handled on separate levels, much like what is done at busy airports. At Penn Station, the greatest need is to transfer quickly and easily to the subways or to reach the street. Regional Rail advocates see an important additional passenger movement, transferring between trains that would hub at Penn Station. These passenger movements would be best accomplished at the level immediately above the tracks. This reduces vertical circulation requirements and saves travel time. The immediate challenge is to reconfigure this level, removing unneeded concessions and train support facilities while adding more stairways to the platforms and opening more space for passenger movement. It would be important for the new Governor to call for a fresh approach to redoing Penn Station that puts passenger circulation first, and then adds the ceremonial icing. Celebrating arrival is important, but just getting there should be the priority George Haikalis, ESPA Manhattan Coordinator for Regional Rail
Mary Peters is new USDOT SecretaryOn September 5th President Bush nominated Mary Peters to replace Norman Mineta as Secretary of Transportation and the Senate confirmed her appointment on September 30th. Ms. Peters spent most of her prior career in the Arizona Department of Transportation and became its director in 1998. She was praised by National Association of Railroad Passengers President George Chilson, who lived in Arizona during her tenure there. She won praise by both Democrats and Republicans at a September 20th Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee hearing, and on September 25th the Committee voted unanimously to recommend her confirmation. In a September 8th statement submitted to the Senate Committee, Chilson said she was “smart, creative and action oriented as well as open minded,” and had “a strong belief in multi-modal transportation.” At her confirmation hearing she said “I agree that we need a national rail passenger system;” she also supported state flexibility to use Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality funds for rail, as Maine has been doing. But after taking office she began to sound a bit like a milder version of her predecessor Mineta, who resigned in July. According to an October 17th Associated Press report she said she wants to “help prod (Amtrak) into replacing a failed business model and (said) long distance routes may have to be pruned in whole or in part...particularly....where alternatives such as subsidized air service are available.” On a more positive note she supported stable funding: “I would like to see us get on a model where we could agree to fund Amtrak over a period so we could make the necessary investments that you can’t make if you’re going on a year to year basis.” And unlike Mineta, she said she actually wants to ride a long distance train: “I want to see what the routes are like, how many people are on the train...I think I need to experience it firsthand.” Peters began her career with the Arizona Department of Transportation in 1985 and remained there until 2001 when she was appointed Federal Highway Administrator. Regarding highways she has supported private sector partnerships and toll roads to raise funds for road building as an alternative to higher taxation. Last November she returned to Arizona (briefly as it turned out), to become National Director for Transportation Policy for HDR, Inc., an engineering design and consulting firm based in Omaha. All in all, with both new enlightened leadership in DOT and FRA in the Administration and the changes in Congress, there is cause for optimism.
Rail Funds Deleted from Security Bill
Last month Congress approved S-4954,the massive Port Security bill, but only after deleting $1.15 billion which Senator John McCain added for rail and transit security improvements. McCain’s website said this was based on S-1379, the Rail Security Act from last year, which would have authorized over $100 million annually for security improvements in Amtrak tunnels in New York, Baltimore and Washington. The Senate approved a similar bill last year.
Frank Barry (from NARP Hotlines)
NARP ADA Resolution Mentions Lyons
At its Fall Board meeting in Austin, TX last month, the National Association of Railroad Passengers (NARP) Board of Directors passed a resolution protesting USDOT’s proposed full length level boarding platform requirement under the Americans with Disabilities Act. The resolution specifically mentions Lyons, NY as one of the communities that would be negatively affected by the full length requirement. Lyons has been working to build a passenger station for more than 15 years, but each time they have acquired the funding they thought was needed, the owner of the freight railroad has raised its requirements.
Frank Barry
ESPA Regional Rail Forum Held In New York City
Over 35 ESPA members and other rail advocates attended the September 30th Regional Rail Forum held in New York City. The Forum was scheduled to coincide with the Institute for Rational Urban Mobility (IRUM) exhibit ‘Making the Connection: Moving Forward on Regional Rail’, on display at the time.
•The need to energize cooperative efforts on both sides of the Hudson River to advance Regional Rail, beginning with the introduction of thru-running service at Penn Station, which could increase peak-hour capacity by 25 to 50%. Endorsed by both ESPA and NJ-ARP three years ago, the Penn Station Metro-Hub plan would serve as a short-term action step. •The desirability of returning the focus of the new Hudson River tunnel project to allow for direct East Midtown access via a Penn Station - Grand Central connection. This connection would be important not only for commuters but also for intercity passengers as well, because it would allow Northeast Corridor and Upstate New York trains to pass through both Manhattan terminals. MTA, NJ Transit and the Port Authority developed an alternative for connecting these two stations during the Major Investment Study phase of planning for the new tunnel, but this alternative has since been rejected. New York’s new Governor should insist that this alternative plan be revisited and that an unbiased review of the concept be conducted. ESPA and NJ-ARP solidly support this connection.
•The need to initiate an objective review of the Grand Central Terminal upper level alternative to avoid the need for a new 150 foot below ground level deep cavern station for the planned Long Island RR East Side Access project. Saving both considerable time and money, making use of the current capacity at GCT could speed the completion of this vital regional link by at least three years. The new Governor should request that the MTA give this option serious consideration and be required to provide a careful objective review.
New Trains Run in Other States
Amtrak’s new Fall timetable shows significant increases in train service in several states as follows:
Branch Lines Blues
Preliminary steps necessary to abandon rail service on the Utica to Binghamton rail corridor have been taken by the New York Susquehanna and Western Railroad (NYSW). Severe flooding in June washed out significant portions of the main line between Sangerfield (near Waterville) and Chenango Forks and traffic levels may not warrant repairing the 61 mile stretch. Therefore, the Railroad has published an updated system map pursuant to Surface Transportation Board guidelines for lines under consideration for abandonment. Specifically, the document identifies the 60.88 mile segment of the Utica Main Line between Chenango Forks and Sangerfield as the subject of abandonment or discontinuance application within three years of the September notice.
Further storm clouds have gathered over the branch as a result of a new proposal that uses a portion of the branch to co-locate a line side power transmission system between Utica and Orange County. The flood gates have opened on widespread public outrage over the project which critics point out will increase upstate electric rates to reduce New York City area rates. Political leaders throughout the proposed route have been swift to react to even the consideration of the proposal.
Ben Gottfried
Train Riding in Britain
Britain is a great place to ride trains. Service is frequent and the equipment is in excellent running condition. We rode on Alstrom “pendolino” trainsets running on Virgin Railways routes to Liverpool and the north coast of Wales. These trainsets came in two versions, electric and multiple unit MU’s. The “pendolino” tilt mechanism made the train feel as though the curves had super elevations beyond what the actually the case outside the windows. This was a good thing as the “drivers” in the cab up front preferred the throttle in “run 8” (or the British equivalent thereof) on these speedy units. Ben Gottfried
Catskill Mountain Rail Corridor Celebration
AVolunteers gathered on October 7, 2006 in Roxbury New York to celebrate a year of achievement on a Catskill Mountain transportation gem, the 61 mile former Ulster & Delaware railroad (U&D) between Kingston on the Hudson River and the metropolitan “Hubbell Corners” region of Stamford. The celebration marked the official opening of the Roxbury Depot Museum in the Northwestern Catskill Mountains at mile post 59 on the U&D line. This former West Shore Railroad route is dotted with three passenger railway operations (at Kingston, Phoenicia and Arkville) a few washouts and controversy over future use of the corridor.
In addition to museum related activities, volunteers have cleared about 20 miles of overgrown track at various points along the route, allowing for maintenance operations over most of the 61 mile line.
Empire Corridor Travel Tips and Discounts…o All Empire Corridor trains NOW require reservations. While advance reservations are encouraged, last minute passengers will always be accommodated if space is available on a particular train. Booking as early as possible will provide the best possible fare. Amtrak accepts reservations up to 11 months in advance of your travel date! Travel during off-peak periods (mid-week, early morning or late evening) will generally be the least expensive. o In conjunction with the 2006 ‘New York By Rail’ Travel Guide, Amtrak is offering a ‘50% Off Companion Fare’ discount between all New York State destinations on Empire Service trains; on the Maple Leaf as far as Niagara Falls, NY; on the Adirondack to Montreal and on the Ethan Allen Express to Rutland. Travelers can save 50% off a second adult fare when traveling in pairs. The discount is valid through April 2007, using discount code V707. Specific advance purchase requirements, blackout dates and other restrictions apply. Contact Amtrak for full details… o Amtrak ‘Share Fares’ are now being offered through mid-December on trains operating between Albany and New York City. Small groups of three to six passengers traveling together can save 25% to 50%. Use promotion code H620 when making reservations and contact Amtrak for full information on specific advance purchase requirements, blackout dates and other restrictions. o AAA and NARP members receive 10% off most regular fares, with a three-day advance purchase requirement. o Visit http://www.amtrak.com and select ‘Hot Deals’ for the latest discount program information. o Join the Amtrak Guest Rewards program and earn points towards free travel and more.
2006-2007 ESPA Meeting Dates
Saturday, January 20, 2007 Schenectady – The Parker Inn
Amtrak Seeks ESPA’s InputAmtrak’s Empire District Superintendent, James Turngren, wants to hear of your New York State Amtrak travel experiences. Whether everything was great or if there was room for improvement, Jim welcomes our input, as he strives to provide the best possible service on the Empire Corridor.
Please send your written trip reports and comments, including specific dates, train numbers and employee names as appropriate to: James Turngren, District Superintendent, Empire District, Amtrak 525 East Street
Please also send a copy to Bruce Becker, so we can track trip experiences and follow up as necessary. Thanks for your help…
|
|
|||||||||||||||
©2005 Empire State Passengers Association, All Rights Reserved |